Discover Vibrating, Gem, Stainless Steel, and Bunny Tail Butt Plugs

Butt plugs offer a wide range of benefits, making them a popular choice for those exploring anal play or looking to enhance their pleasure. The variety of styles and materials available ensures there is a butt plug for everyone, regardless of experience level. For beginners, a small vibrating butt plug or gem butt plug can offer gentle stimulation and comfort, while those more experienced may prefer larger options like large butt plugs or thrusting butt plugs for deeper, more intense sensations.

A bunny tail butt plug or butt plug tail adds a playful and aesthetic element to the experience, while providing enjoyable sensations. For those seeking more dynamic pleasure, a vibrating anal plug or vibrating butt plug can offer continuous stimulation, heightening pleasure and excitement during use. Additionally, thrusting butt plugs are designed to mimic the movement of penetration, creating an even more immersive experience.

  • Crystal Rose Butt Plug – Pink $49.17 $46.71 20 Reward Points

    Crystal Glass is 100% hygienically superior borosilicate glass. Annealed for safety and available is a variety of shapes and sizes. Suitable with all lubricants.

    1 in stock

  • Neon Bunny Tail Plug Pink $35.01 $33.26 20 Reward Points

    Perfect for those new to anal play, the Neon Butt Plug is just what you need to explore the amazing world of anal stimulation. Made from super smooth flexible silicone, the tapered tip inserts easily and the slender shape provides exciting pleasure. The fluffy bunny tail ensures it will not slip too far inside and adds fun to all your sexy adventures! From Pipedream.

    28 in stock

  • Crystal Gem Butt Plug – Purple $50.07 $47.57 20 Reward Points

    Crystal Glass is 100% hygienically superior borosilicate glass. Annealed for safety and available is a variety of shapes and sizes. Suitable with all lubricants.

    95 in stock

  • Ass-sation Remote Vibrating Metal Anal Ecstasy – Black $140.16 $133.15 20 Reward Points

    Ass-Sation brings together metal and vibration for orgasmic results. For lovers of metal sex toys, you can now take part in a vibration in your favorite material sensation. Explore 10 different vibrating functions using the controls on the toy or the handy remote control. Try immersing the Ass-Sation Remote Control Vibrating Metal Butt Plug in warm or cool water beforehand for fun sensation play. The Ecstacy Plug is a semi-realistic cock-shaped plug that is ideal for all-day wear. The shaft is smooth and straight, with a softly pronounced cock head. The curved tip and plump penis head are sure to hit just the right spot every time. Use with any of your favorite lubricants. After use, carefully wash the toy with mild soap and water or Toy Cleaner for even quicker cleanup.

    42 in stock

  • Tailz Snap On Interchangeable Fox Tail – Black $42.45 $40.33 20 Reward Points

    Tailz Snap-Ons are crafted for true animal roleplay enthusiasts! These interchangeable tails feature a nifty silicone cap at their base, allowing you to easily detach and switch with other Tailz Snap-on attachments. Designed for use with Tailz Snap-On Butt Plugs – collect a variety of styles and colors that suit your fantasy! Each Tailz Snap-on is made with super soft, vegan friendly faux fur – perfect for all kinds of kinky, animal centric fun!This Black Fox Tail is thick, long, and furry! Pair this 16 inch black beauty with your favorite set of dark lingerie, leathers, or other dark accessories and unleash your inner fox. Complete your foxy appearance and indulge in kinky primal play with your partner.Spot clean this fox tail after use with a damp cloth and blow dry as needed.

    7 in stock

  • Pighole Squeal Ff Hollow Plug – Black $335.64 $318.86 20 Reward Points

    PIGHOLE SQUEAL FF is our biggest pluggable, toyable hollow plug. This is a big toy for advanced butt-pluggers and FFisting pros. The veiny outside texture keeps this plug in place, the inner texture rings are for more pleasure. We hand pour these in small batches in Los Angeles—it's the only way to get the warm glossy liquid silicone finish—Platinum Cure silicone, it's the absolute best for feel and flexibility. Just the right stretch, keeps the hole open, it doesn't collapse, but flexible enough to fold for insertion.

    1 in stock

  • Oxballs Ergo Buttplug Large – Police Swirl $240.00 $228.00 20 Reward Points
    ERGO is a super smooth silicone buttplug designed for comfort. Its kidney bean shape and tapered neck are designed to keep ERGO snugly in place. It's made from high quality Pure Platinum Silicone so it's blubbery and flesh-like, perfect for comfortable insertion. Each ERGO buttplug is hand poured in our factory so no two plugs alike. It's available in 5 sizes ranging from beginner to advanced hole-stretcher.
    L: Length: 5.5”/ 13.97 cm. Usable Length: 4.75” Largest Usable Circumference: 7.25”/ Smallest Usable Circumference: 4.25”.

    2 in stock

  • B-vibe Weighted Snug Plug 6 – 515 G Marine $168.75 $160.31 20 Reward Points
    Designed for comfort and to induce feelings of fullness, each Snug Plug is made of seamless, body-safe silicone, and features a thin, flexible neck and smooth grip handle. 
    Features: Seamless, silicone plug. Rounded edge for easy insertion. Precision shaped for erotic sensations. Weighted balls provide sensual feeling of fullness. Thin 1cm flexible neck. Comfortable smooth grip handle.
    Includes travel/storage case & guide to Anal play from b-Vibe.
    Dimensions: 515 g weighted plug 
    Size: 2.2 x 6.3 inches. 
    One year warranty. 
    **Amazon Marketplace, Ebay, Jet or other 3rd party websites must be listed at a price equal to or greater than the MSRP. For auctions, the reserve and/ or opening bids must start at MAP without a “Buy it Now” option. Best Offer Auctions are not allowed.

    5 in stock

  • Dorcel Aluminium Bejeweled Diamond Plug – Rose Gold Medium $34.50 $32.78 20 Reward Points

    Diamond Plug is a metal butt plug that is easy to insert due to its round shape. The butt plug ensures safe penetration due to the flat bottom. The aluminum alloy material reacts to temperature, allowing users to experiment with temperature. Temperature sensitive metal. Pointed tip for easy insertion. Flat base for safe penetration. Elegant diamond design.

    Material: Aluminum.
    Dimensions: Overall Length – 3.26 inches Insertable Length – 1.97 inches Width – 1.34 inches

    36 in stock

  • Nexus Simul8 Plug Cock Ring Anal Plug Black $159.36 $151.39 20 Reward Points

    Nexus Simul8 Butt Plug Edition delivers maximum satisfaction to both you and your partner. The super soft and stretchy silicone cock and balls ring will keep you harder for longer while the ergonomically shaped vibrating butt plug and base will stimulate your prostate and perineum as you thrust.

    Nexus Simul8 Vibrating Double Cock Ring and Anal Plug features 6 vibration modes. 2 motors. 48 combinations of pleasure. USB rechargeable. Waterproof submersible. 1 year warranty.

    8 in stock

  • Oxballs Ergo Buttplug X Large- Platinum Swirl $333.75 $317.06 20 Reward Points

    Oxballs ERGO buttplug to fits your hole right—it feels amazing ‘cause it hits the right spot, twist it and feel how it rubs your prostate, and the base is sized to keep this plug in… There is a reason it is our most popular buttplug—it feels amazing! Hand poured in small batches using liquid platinum cure silicone. Oxballs loves color, so we've added NEW platinum color to ERGO—it's a swirl of metallic platinum and black—kinda fancy for a toy you put in your butthole, but it is sexy AF and so much cooler than boring solid black! Each one is unique with cool color swirls .XL: Length: 6”/ 15.24 cm Usable Length: 5.75”/ 14.605 cm Largest Usable Circumference: 8.5”/ 21.59 cm Smallest Usable Circumference: 4.75”/ 12.065 cm

    1 in stock

  • Oxballs Ergo Buttplug Medium – Police Swirl $183.75 $174.56 20 Reward Points
    ERGO is a super smooth silicone buttplug designed for comfort. Its kidney bean shape and tapered neck are designed to keep ERGO snugly in place. It's made from high quality Pure Platinum Silicone so it's blubbery and flesh-like, perfect for comfortable insertion. Each ERGO buttplug is hand poured in our factory so no two plugs alike. It's available in 5 sizes ranging from beginner to advanced hole-stretcher.
    M : Length: 4.25”/ 10.795 cm Usable Length: 3.75”/ 9.525 cm Largest Usable Circumference: 6.25”/ 15.875 cm Smallest Usable Circumference: 3.75”/ 9.525 cm.

    1 in stock

  • In A Bag 3″ Vibrating Butt Plug – Black $42.06 $39.96 20 Reward Points

    Doc Johnson's classic shape gains extra power with a vibrating bullet. The plug itself is tapered for easy insertion and made from firm-yet-flexible health-grade silicone. This Vibrating Butt Plug has 3 inches of insertable length, perfect for beginners, and its soft finish and wide base ensure comfort and safety during wear. The included 10-function bullet will keep you busy all night long.

    28 in stock

  • Bfilled Basic Plus – Magenta $44.16 $41.95 20 Reward Points

    Did you know the anal area has such a high concentration of nerve endings that even the smallest plug can feel amazing? The Bfilled Basic Plus massaging plug was designed with this in mind. Expertly defined contours, a flared base, and 100% body safe (and soft) silicone keep play as exciting as it is safe. It's also a non-motorized plug, getting its vibes from a free-floating weight inside that delivers the most arousing rush. And because there are no batteries required, clean-up is fast and easy.

    2 in stock

  • Xgen Bodywand Mini Vibes Pop – Black $108.54 $103.11

    Boasting a sleek, gorgeous black design, the Bodywand Mini Vibes Pop is a feast for the eyes. The tapered tip is designed to make insertion easy that is perfect for beginners, while the t-bar base prevents any accidental slips while also engaging the perineum.

    69 in stock

  • Evolved Plug & Play Remote Anal Plug – Black $187.47 $178.10

    This game-changing butt plug is made from unusually soft and squishy silicone, perfect for anal play. The tapered triangle shape lets you decide how far you'd like to go as you experiment with 7 vibration speeds and functions. Use the convenient wireless remote to play solo or give it to your partner to amp up some naughty fun!. Retrieval cord for safety. 1 button push controls at base and on remote. Wireless controller lets you play from 70 feet away. Waterproof and submersible. Five year warranty.

    14 in stock

  • Dorcel Best Plug Starter Kit S/m – Black $124.68 $118.45

    Add a playful touch to your celebration with Glitterati Confetti Penis Party decorations by Little Genie! Ideal for bachelorette parties, bachelor parties, or any cheeky gathering, this vibrant confetti features eye-catching designs in a mix of colors that will elevate the fun. Made from high-quality materials, the confetti is perfect for sprinkling on tables, filling balloons, or enhancing gift bags. Create a memorable atmosphere filled with laughter and excitement that your guests will rave about long after the party ends!

    10 in stock

  • Dorcel Best Plug Expert Kit M/l – Black $172.23 $163.62

    Elevate your celebration with the Glitterati Penis Party Candles! This dazzling pack of five features vibrant, sparkly designs that are perfect for adding a cheeky touch to any birthday or bachelorette party. Each candle is finely crafted to stand tall on your favorite cake, delivering a playful vibe that’s sure to spark laughter and joy. Their eye-catching glitter finish glimmers and shines, making them a fun centerpiece for your festivities. With these whimsical candles, your party will be unforgettable! Light up the night with charm and humor!

    27 in stock

  • Simpli Trading Silicone Butt Plug – Small $80.16 $76.15

    Ecommerce sales only. Not packaged for retail sale.

    2 in stock

  • Inflatable Vibrating Butt Plug Black $189.78 $180.29

    Introducing the Spartacus PU Riding Crop with a delightful plush heart-shaped tip, combining elegance and playfulness in one enticing package. This high-quality riding crop is perfect for those looking to explore bondage and spanking in a fun yet sensual way. The soft heart tip adds a romantic touch, making it an ideal choice for couples seeking to spice up their intimate moments. Crafted for both comfort and performance, this versatile sex toy guarantees an exciting experience, whether you’re a beginner or an experienced player in the world of BDSM.

    13 in stock

  • Gender Fluid Excite! Plug – Rose Gold $44.52 $42.29

    Excite! Plug. From Gender Fluid. Smooth, tapered design for easy insertion. Ideal for temperature play. Suitable with all lubricants.

    9 in stock

  • Gender Fluid Excite! Extendo Plug – Silver $67.05 $63.70

    Excite! Plug. From Gender Fluid. Smooth, tapered design with three screw rings for extra stimulation. Ideal for temperature play. Suitable with all lubricants.

    5 in stock

  • Pink Elephant Lil Rumble Rechargeable Vibe W/remote – Black $120.00 $114.00

    Introducing the “Hello Sexy! Tease Me, Please Me Finger Vibe” – a delightful addition to your intimate adventures! This sleek and powerful finger vibe features 8 exciting speeds and 20 tantalizing patterns, allowing you to customize your pleasure experience. With its USB rechargeable design, you’ll never run out of fun when you need it most. Plus, being waterproof means you can enjoy your favorite sensations in the bath or shower. Indulge in intimate moments and explore new heights of satisfaction with this versatile vibe!

    30 in stock

  • Pink Elephant Dreamer Rechargeable Vibe W/remote – Aqua $120.00 $114.00

    Discover ultimate relaxation with the Mini Halo Wireless 20x Wand from Voodoo Toys. Featuring 20 unique vibration patterns and 8 adjustable speed strengths, you can customize your massage experience to suit your preferences. Its bendable neck allows for flexible positioning, delivering soothing sensations exactly where you need them most. With a powerful yet whisper-quiet motor, you can indulge without disturbing your peace. Crafted from soft silicone, this wand is 100% waterproof and USB rechargeable, making it the perfect companion for pleasure anytime, anywhere. Cable included for your convenience.

    33 in stock

  • Secret Kisses 4.5″ Handblown Wide Glass Plug – Black/gold $67.32 $63.95

    Expand the horizons of your intimate play with the Secret Kisses 4.5” Handblown Glass Plug. Featuring a smooth tip for easy insertion, this plug features a filling sensation throughout its shaft down to its neck and flared base.

    25 in stock

  • Satisfyer Lolli Plug 1 – Berry $93.66 $88.98

    Time to get jolly with the LOLLI collection! The LOLLI PLUG 1, endowed with 3 ascending diamond shaped beads perfectly fill, caress, and press all of your anal pleasure points. Suitable for beginners and more advanced players, these sensual plugs offer two strong and strategically located motors and are made of soft, body-friendly, silicone. The tantalizing vibrations within the beads offer a unique rolling vibration which will tantalize and seduce you into heightened states of bliss. – Body-friendly silicone – Whisper mode – Rechargeable – Waterproof IPX7 – Size: 139 mm x 71 mm x 32 mm.

    61 in stock

  • Satisfyer Plug-ilicious 2 – Ice Blue $125.94 $119.64

    Thanks to its conical shape and rounded tip, the Plug-ilicious 2 hits the P-point precisely, stimulating it with vibrations from 2 motors. The wonderful design is rounded off with a wide base, soft silicone material and app control.Compatible with the free Satisfyer AppAvailable on iOS and Android.App offers an unending range of programmes.Preset programmes can be edited.Can also be used without the app.The 2 motors can be controlled separately, allowing for numerous vibration combination options.Super-strong deep vibration.Suitable for all genders.Waterproof (IPX7).Whisper mode.USB rechargeable, magnetic USB charging cable included.Easy to clean.Body-friendly silicone.Dimensions:Length – 5.3 inches.Width – 1.6 inches.

    46 in stock

  • Star Fucker Glider Gem Plug W/silicone Enhancer – Black $64.14 $60.93

    Blast off to a universe of personalized pleasure with the Star Fucker? Glider Plug. A stretchy, silicone dual enhancer is paired with a sleek, seamless metal probe for versatile support, enhancement, and even tantalizing temperature play. The supple silicone dual enhancer was created to increase stamina, improve sensitivity and deliver superior erection support. Get playful by using the dual enhancer and metallic probe together, and don't forget they can be disassembled for easy cleaning. The flexible probe is made from a smooth, seamless aluminum alloy that retains heat or cold for a one-of-a-kind temperature play experience. While you expand your horizons with the sleek bulbous plug, use the sparkling gem adorned base for steamy stimulation, effortless insertion and gentle removal. The view gets even better from behind with the sparkling gem base.

    47 in stock

  • Pink Elephant Buzzy Bae Rechargeable Vibe W/remote – Black $120.00 $114.00

    Discover the Mini Halo Wireless 20x Wand from Voodoo Toys, a powerful and versatile personal massager designed to elevate your relaxation experience. With 20 unique vibration patterns and 8 adjustable speed settings, you can effortlessly customize your massage to suit your preferences. The wand features a bendable neck, allowing for targeted relief exactly where you need it. Crafted from high-quality silicone and equipped with a robust motor, it delivers strong yet whisper-quiet vibrations. Plus, it’s 100% waterproof and USB rechargeable, making it perfect for use in any setting. Enjoy indulgent self-care with the Mini Halo Wand!

    27 in stock

  • Pink Elephant Dreamer Rechargeable Vibe W/remote – Black $120.00 $114.00

    Discover ultimate relaxation with the Mini Halo Wireless 20x Wand from Voodoo Toys. Featuring 20 unique vibration patterns and 8 adjustable speed strengths, you can customize your massage experience to suit your preferences. Its bendable neck allows for flexible positioning, delivering soothing sensations exactly where you need them most. With a powerful yet whisper-quiet motor, you can indulge without disturbing your peace. Crafted from soft silicone, this wand is 100% waterproof and USB rechargeable, making it the perfect companion for pleasure anytime, anywhere. Cable included for your convenience.

    26 in stock

Butt plugs come in various materials, including stainless steel, glass, and silicone, each offering unique benefits. Stainless steel butt plugs are durable, easy to clean, and provide a satisfying weight, while glass butt plugs are sleek, firm, and perfect for temperature play. Silicone butt plugs are soft, flexible, and comfortable for extended wear.

For gay men, gay butt plugs offer a tailored experience, combining functionality with pleasure. Overall, butt plugs are versatile, safe, and can significantly enhance your anal play, adding new dimensions to your intimate experiences.

Out of Stock

  • Anal Fantasy Ass Gasm Advanced Plug Cock Ring Black $60.78 $57.74

    Enjoy the most explosive ejaculations ever with the Ass-Gasm Cockring Advanced Plug. Made entirely from silky smooth Elite Silicone, this wearable plug doubles as a performance-enhancing cockring, allowing the wearer to prolong ejaculation and extend the fun while enjoying incredible prostate stimulation. The Ass-Gasm Cockring Advanced Plug features a unique base that was strategically designed to allow the user to gently apply pressure at the bottom of the plug to comfortably ease into insertion. Ultra hygienic Elite Silicone is phthalate free, hypoallergenic, and super flexible.

    Insertable length 4 inches plug, width, diameter 1.6 inches, cock ring diameter 1.6 inchs. From Pipedream Products.

    Out of stock

  • Electrastim X Mr. S Leather – World’s Most Comfortable Silicone Electro Butt Plug – Black $97.98 $93.08

    ElectraStim x Mr. S Leather – World’s Most Comfortable Silicone Electro Butt Plug. Designed in collaboration with Mr. S Leather, the largest and longest standing fetish brand in the USA (since 1979!) we’ve lent our electro expertise to their World’s Most Comfortable Butt Plug for this Silicone Electro edition. Since 1997 this classic design has been a part of Mr. S’s butt toy arsenal; this time though the World’s Most Comfortable Silicone Electro Butt Plug is made from our proprietary blend of electro conductive silicone for an added oomph to play. We’ve retained all the heft of the original plug with a solid steel weighted core and a ‘stealth entry’ cable system that allows for comfortable and secure seated play. Compatible with all ElectraStim stimulators- sold separately.

    Out of stock

  • Playboy Pleasure Tux Butt Plug – Large $63.12 $59.96

    Experience unparalleled pleasure with this expertly designed sex toy, engineered for both comfort and intensity. Its unique ergonomic shape cradles your anatomy, firmly gripping the base of your shaft to provide unwavering hardness while elevating your desires. The anatomical channel allows for seamless urination while erect and eliminates the constrictive feeling often found with traditional cock rings. Perfect for sustained sessions or intense encounters, it’s lube safe and lightweight, ensuring maximum enjoyment. With optimal dimensions and a focus on pleasure, this toy heightens arousal like never before.

    Out of stock

  • Boundless Teardrop Plug $16.59 $15.76

    Pleasure is made endless with the bold Boundless Teardrop Plug. The passionate plug is made for streamlined pleasure with a perfectly petite teardrop design, flexible body, and easy pull handle base.The pliable probe is gently tapered for playful training, but is sure to thrill even the most seasoned anal player. While you indulge in knee-shaking sensations, use the easy pull base for steamy stimulation, effortless insertion and gentle removal.The flexible probe is made from a body-safe Silicone with a flexible, seamless body. The body safe material is unscented and phthalate free to keep your most sensitive spots happy and healthy.

    Out of stock

  • Reggie Tapping Anal Plug – Black $57.00 $54.15

    Reggie Tapping Anal Plug Remote Control. Luxury design,Adding 2 Sides Bullets Vibrating . 10 Speeds Vibrating. 10 Speeds Tapping . Ultra Soft Texual Silicone. Waterproof and rechargeable . Easy to clean. 10 meters remote control.

    Out of stock

  • Doro Plus Vibrating Anal Plug With Remote Control – Pink $97.11 $92.25

    Elevate your party experience with the Rainbow Light Up Pecker Shot Glass! Bursting with vibrant rainbow stripes, this eye-catching glass is perfect for adding a playful touch to any celebration. Its enchanting light-up feature guarantees to grab attention and enhance the festive mood. Designed for both fun and functionality, it comes with a convenient hang string for easy access. Batteries are included, so you can dive straight into the party without delay. Make a bold statement and celebrate with sass, courtesy of Hott Products!

    Out of stock

  • Pretty Love 4.92 inches Silicone Anal Plug with Ball Black $37.32 $35.45

    Pretty Love 4.92 inches Silicone Anal Plug with Ball Black. Silicone anal plug with ball. Silicone, 4.92 inches insertable and 1.1 inches diameter. From Pretty Love.

    Out of stock

  • Punishment Fox Tail Plug – Black $32.31 $30.69

    Release your wild side with the Punishment Fox Tail Silicone Plug! Punish your partner with cuteness when you wear this naughty tail plug! Explore the pleasures of anal play with this beginner-friendly anal plug. The smooth silicone and tapered tip are perfectly designed for easy insertion. Experience the exhilaration of this smooth plug as you slide it in, giving you a satisfying filling feeling. Discover the popping pleasure of pulling it out slowly yourself, or let your partner take control. Slip on the included blindfold to add a little mystery and intensify your senses. The faux-fur tail is extremely soft and lightweight, so flick your hips and wag that tail, you’ll enrapture your partner without fail! Complete the look with some sexy lingerie and cute animal ears. If you’re really feeling adventurous add a naughty leash to the mix and let your partner lead you on a trip of kinky fun. Use with a water-based lubricant for the highest level of comfort and clean with a toy cleaner before and after every use. It’s time to be punished by pleasure with Punishment.

    Out of stock

  • Sport Fucker Thunder Plug Medium – Red $55.35 $52.58

    After more than a year in the making, Sport Fucker has released its revolutionary new Thunder Plug.This butt plug actually TAPS your prostate as you move! There is a three part interior which creates a deep, penetrating thud. The thin neck and ergonomic flange were designed to be worn all day. When worn for an extended period of time, the constant and steady tapping on the prostate will slowly and steadily cause your cock to leak. Try and find another plug to do that!This butt plug is sure to be one of our all-time best sellers.”The shape doesn’t seem to make sense at first, until you use it. It’s our favorite plug”

    Out of stock

  • B-vibe Weighted Snug Plug 1 – 55 G Mint $93.75 $89.06

    From B-Vibe. Designed for comfort and to induce feelings of fullness, each Snug Plug is made of seamless, body-safe silicone, and features a thin, flexible neck and smooth grip handle. Features: Seamless, silicone plug. Rounded edge for easy insertion. Precision shaped for erotic sensations. Weighted balls provide sensual feeling of fullness. Thin 1cm flexible neck. Comfortable smooth grip handle. Includes travel/storage case & guide to Anal play from b-Vibe. One Year Warranty. When listing on eBay, Groupon, Jet or other 3rd party websites, the price must be equal to or greater than the MSRP. For auctions,the reserve and/ or opening bids must start at MAP without a “Buy It Now” option. Best Offer Auctions are not allowed. COTR does not allow the sale of our products on Amazon

    Out of stock

My Cart
Wishlist
Recently Viewed
Categories
FREE ADULT TOYS & SPECIAL OFFERS

for Subscribers

We’re here to enhance your sex life with expert tips, exclusive offers, and free toys!